{"id":2629,"date":"2025-09-14T08:22:42","date_gmt":"2025-09-14T08:22:42","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/?p=2629"},"modified":"2025-09-14T08:41:03","modified_gmt":"2025-09-14T08:41:03","slug":"beyond-synthesis-a-review-of-epsita-haldars-reclaiming-karbala","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/?p=2629","title":{"rendered":"Beyond Synthesis: A Review of Epsita Haldar\u2019s \u2018Reclaiming Karbala\u2019"},"content":{"rendered":"\t\t<div data-elementor-type=\"wp-post\" data-elementor-id=\"2629\" class=\"elementor elementor-2629\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<section class=\"elementor-section elementor-top-section elementor-element elementor-element-6e80296a elementor-section-boxed elementor-section-height-default elementor-section-height-default\" data-id=\"6e80296a\" data-element_type=\"section\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-container elementor-column-gap-default\">\n\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-column elementor-col-100 elementor-top-column elementor-element elementor-element-209b1b\" data-id=\"209b1b\" data-element_type=\"column\">\n\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-wrap elementor-element-populated\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-element elementor-element-7cf16444 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading\" data-id=\"7cf16444\" data-element_type=\"widget\" data-widget_type=\"heading.default\">\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-container\">\n\t\t\t<style>\/*! elementor - v3.14.0 - 26-06-2023 *\/\n.elementor-heading-title{padding:0;margin:0;line-height:1}.elementor-widget-heading .elementor-heading-title[class*=elementor-size-]>a{color:inherit;font-size:inherit;line-height:inherit}.elementor-widget-heading .elementor-heading-title.elementor-size-small{font-size:15px}.elementor-widget-heading .elementor-heading-title.elementor-size-medium{font-size:19px}.elementor-widget-heading .elementor-heading-title.elementor-size-large{font-size:29px}.elementor-widget-heading .elementor-heading-title.elementor-size-xl{font-size:39px}.elementor-widget-heading .elementor-heading-title.elementor-size-xxl{font-size:59px}<\/style><h1 class=\"elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default\">Beyond Synthesis: A Review of Epsita Haldar\u2019s \u2018Reclaiming Karbala\u2019<\/h1>\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/section>\n\t\t\t\t<section class=\"elementor-section elementor-top-section elementor-element elementor-element-e712b59 elementor-section-boxed elementor-section-height-default elementor-section-height-default\" data-id=\"e712b59\" data-element_type=\"section\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-container elementor-column-gap-default\">\n\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-column elementor-col-100 elementor-top-column elementor-element elementor-element-621b9945\" data-id=\"621b9945\" data-element_type=\"column\">\n\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-wrap elementor-element-populated\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-element elementor-element-26cf697b elementor-widget elementor-widget-post-info\" data-id=\"26cf697b\" data-element_type=\"widget\" data-widget_type=\"post-info.default\">\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-container\">\n\t\t\t<link rel=\"stylesheet\" href=\"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/wp-content\/plugins\/elementor\/assets\/css\/widget-icon-list.min.css\"><link rel=\"stylesheet\" href=\"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/wp-content\/plugins\/elementor-pro\/assets\/css\/widget-theme-elements.min.css\">\t\t<ul class=\"elementor-inline-items elementor-icon-list-items elementor-post-info\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<li class=\"elementor-icon-list-item elementor-repeater-item-773f523 elementor-inline-item\" itemprop=\"datePublished\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<a href=\"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/?m=20250914\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<span class=\"elementor-icon-list-icon\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<svg xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" id=\"Layer_2\" data-name=\"Layer 2\" viewBox=\"0 0 29.01 29.01\"><g id=\"Layer_1-2\" data-name=\"Layer 1\"><path d=\"M10.15,0V2.9h8.7V0h2.9V2.9h5.8c.8,0,1.45,.65,1.45,1.45V27.56c0,.8-.65,1.45-1.45,1.45H1.45c-.8,0-1.45-.65-1.45-1.45V4.35c0-.8,.65-1.45,1.45-1.45H7.25V0h2.9Zm15.96,14.5H2.9v11.6H26.11V14.5Zm-13.05,2.9v5.8H5.8v-5.8h7.25ZM7.25,5.8H2.9v5.8H26.11V5.8h-4.35v2.9h-2.9v-2.9H10.15v2.9h-2.9v-2.9Z\"><\/path><\/g><\/svg>\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/span>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<span class=\"elementor-icon-list-text elementor-post-info__item elementor-post-info__item--type-date\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\tSeptember 14, 2025\t\t\t\t\t<\/span>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/a>\n\t\t\t\t<\/li>\n\t\t\t\t<li class=\"elementor-icon-list-item elementor-repeater-item-a3539ae elementor-inline-item\" itemprop=\"author\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<a href=\"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/?author=10\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<span class=\"elementor-icon-list-icon\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<svg xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" id=\"Layer_2\" data-name=\"Layer 2\" viewBox=\"0 0 22.97 30.15\"><g id=\"Layer_1-2\" data-name=\"Layer 1\"><path d=\"M0,30.15c0-6.34,5.14-11.49,11.49-11.49s11.49,5.14,11.49,11.49h-2.87c0-4.76-3.86-8.61-8.61-8.61S2.87,25.39,2.87,30.15H0Zm11.49-12.92c-4.76,0-8.61-3.86-8.61-8.61S6.73,0,11.49,0s8.61,3.86,8.61,8.61-3.86,8.61-8.61,8.61Zm0-2.87c3.17,0,5.74-2.57,5.74-5.74s-2.57-5.74-5.74-5.74-5.74,2.57-5.74,5.74,2.57,5.74,5.74,5.74Z\"><\/path><\/g><\/svg>\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/span>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<span class=\"elementor-icon-list-text elementor-post-info__item elementor-post-info__item--type-author\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\tAdnan Mahmud\t\t\t\t\t<\/span>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/a>\n\t\t\t\t<\/li>\n\t\t\t\t<\/ul>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/section>\n\t\t<div class=\"elementor-element elementor-element-73feac8 e-flex e-con-boxed e-con\" data-id=\"73feac8\" data-element_type=\"container\" data-settings=\"{&quot;content_width&quot;:&quot;boxed&quot;}\">\n\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"e-con-inner\">\n\t\t<div class=\"elementor-element elementor-element-1d6c5a2 e-con-full e-flex e-con\" data-id=\"1d6c5a2\" data-element_type=\"container\" data-settings=\"{&quot;background_background&quot;:&quot;classic&quot;,&quot;content_width&quot;:&quot;full&quot;}\">\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-element elementor-element-5666a67 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading\" data-id=\"5666a67\" data-element_type=\"widget\" data-widget_type=\"heading.default\">\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-container\">\n\t\t\t<p class=\"elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default\">Summary<\/p>\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-element elementor-element-770b167 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor\" data-id=\"770b167\" data-element_type=\"widget\" data-widget_type=\"text-editor.default\">\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-container\">\n\t\t\t<style>\/*! elementor - v3.14.0 - 26-06-2023 *\/\n.elementor-widget-text-editor.elementor-drop-cap-view-stacked .elementor-drop-cap{background-color:#69727d;color:#fff}.elementor-widget-text-editor.elementor-drop-cap-view-framed .elementor-drop-cap{color:#69727d;border:3px solid;background-color:transparent}.elementor-widget-text-editor:not(.elementor-drop-cap-view-default) .elementor-drop-cap{margin-top:8px}.elementor-widget-text-editor:not(.elementor-drop-cap-view-default) .elementor-drop-cap-letter{width:1em;height:1em}.elementor-widget-text-editor .elementor-drop-cap{float:left;text-align:center;line-height:1;font-size:50px}.elementor-widget-text-editor .elementor-drop-cap-letter{display:inline-block}<\/style>\t\t\t\t<p style=\"text-align: left;\"><span class=\"citation-3 citation-end-3\">In Reclaiming Karbala, Epsita Haldar challenges traditional views on religious modernization and cultural formation among Bengali Muslims.<\/span> She argues that they developed a unique form of modernity by embracing &#8220;productive ambivalence,&#8221; navigating cultural and religious tensions without a &#8220;facile synthesis.&#8221; <span class=\"citation-2 citation-end-2\">The book demonstrates how they used a &#8220;contact nebula&#8221; of multilingual sources and created new literary forms, like &#8220;composite Bangla,&#8221; to build a distinct national identity while maintaining ties to Islamic heritage.<\/span> Although the book provides a new framework for understanding reform movements beyond orthodox\/heterodox binaries, the review notes some limitations in its analysis of reception practices, geographical scope, and applicability to post-partition contexts.<\/p><p style=\"text-align: right;\">\u00a0<span style=\"background-color: #aa8664; font-family: 'Nanum Gothic Coding', sans-serif; font-size: 12px; color: white;\">\u00a0\u00a0\u24d8 This summary is generated by Ai\u00a0\u00a0<\/span><\/p>\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<section class=\"elementor-section elementor-top-section elementor-element elementor-element-79ca75c9 elementor-section-boxed elementor-section-height-default elementor-section-height-default\" data-id=\"79ca75c9\" data-element_type=\"section\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-container elementor-column-gap-default\">\n\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-column elementor-col-100 elementor-top-column elementor-element elementor-element-43557d5a\" data-id=\"43557d5a\" data-element_type=\"column\">\n\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-wrap elementor-element-populated\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-element elementor-element-0d0d32b elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor\" data-id=\"0d0d32b\" data-element_type=\"widget\" data-widget_type=\"text-editor.default\">\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-container\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"arr--story-page-card-wrapper\"><div class=\"arr--element-container story-element-card-m_element-container__1ZeJL story-element-card-m_dark__1AX15\"><div class=\"arrow-component arr--text-element text-m_textElement__e3QEt text-m_dark__1TC18\" data-test-id=\"text\"><p>\u00a0<\/p><p><strong>Epsita Haldar, <em>Reclaiming Karbala: Nation, Islam and Literature of the Bengali Muslims<\/em><\/strong><\/p><p>Epsita Haldar\u2019s Reclaiming Karbala forces us to undertake a fundamental reckoning with how we understand the processes of religious modernisation, literary formation, and cultural agency in colonial contexts. The book\u2019s empirical richness derives from meticulous multilingual archival work spanning <em>Dobh\u0101sh\u012b<\/em> literature, reformist tracts, institutional records, and print culture materials across Arabic, Persian, Urdu, and Bengali sources. Rather than offering yet another case study of Islamic reform, this work demonstrates how Bengali Muslims created distinctive forms of modernity through what Haldar terms \u2018productive ambivalence\u2019 (p.144): the generative capacity to thrive within the ambiguities of, rather than categorically resolve, fundamental cultural tensions. In fact, Haldar\u2019s intervention is especially noteworthy because it moves beyond what can be characterised as the \u2018curse of the facile synthesis\u2019, that is, the problematic tendency to resolve complex cultural, religious, and intellectual tensions through a facile synthesis or hurried compromise that remains insensitive to deeper asymmetries and hierarchical structures. Haldar demonstrates how Bengali Muslims developed sophisticated cultural technologies for operating \u2018productively\u2019 within unresolved tensions, creating new forms of literary modernity that in its ambition neither rejected Islamic claims to authenticity nor simply accommodated colonial linguistic frameworks.<\/p><p>The theoretical intervention of this book may be understood as a challenge to three dominant analytical paradigms: first, it disrupts linear modernisation narratives by moving \u2018beyond the popular binarism between poetic freedom and religious reform which pits the \u2018modernist\u2019 (<em>\u015aikh\u0101<\/em>) against the \u2018orthodox\u2019 (<em>Moh\u0101mmad\u012b<\/em>)\u2019 (p. 215); second, it contests a recurring colonial model of centre\u2013periphery through an analysis of \u2018<em>mi\u015bra bh\u0101sh\u0101<\/em>\u2019 (composite language) and \u2018local cosmopolitanism,\u2019 which reveals \u2018more nuanced and layered deliberations than a straightforward narrative\u2019 of peripheral dependence (pp. 216, 228); and third, it challenges the orientalist trap of binary thinking that reduces colonial responses to resistance or accommodation, demonstrating instead a \u2018productive ambivalence\u2019 in reformist literature (pp. 214\u2013216). The creative complexity through which colonial communities negotiated multiple modernities simultaneously, moving beyond predetermined theoretical categories, is precisely the reason why these theoretical intervention are non-trivial.<\/p><p>Haldar traces cultural formation through what she terms \u2018contact nebula\u2019 (p.4): transterritorial networks that challenge both Orientalist East-West binaries and nationalist territorial frameworks by revealing how local cultures emerge dynamically through multilingual circulation rather than isolated development. This quasi-cosmological framework becomes particularly evident in Haldar\u2019s treatment of authentication practices; rather than viewing citation systems and textual validation merely as scholarly methods, she demonstrates how these methods functioned as community-building mechanisms that simultaneously established religious authority and created internal hierarchies. Thus, the <em>Dobh\u0101sh\u012b<\/em> authors\u2019 extensive use of Arabic and Persian citations did not simply legitimise their Bengali compositions with a sacred mantle, but also performed the socio-ritual function of defining who properly belonged to the community of authorised knowers whilst enabling creative theological innovation within Islamic frameworks. This approach avoids the binary between reductive syncretism versus vapid orthodoxy that has long dominated South Asian Islamic studies. In other words, instead of asking whether Bengali Muslims were \u2018truly\u2019 Islamic or \u2018syncretically\u2019 Hindu, Haldar examines how they developed what she calls \u2018literary equivalents\u2019 (p.13) through systematic searches for functional parallels with existing Bengali theo-poetical repertoires that preserved Islamic systematic coherence whilst enabling creative adaptation. Indeed, the reformist appropriation of Husayn-centric piety was not a synthesis of <em>Sunni<\/em> and <em>Sh\u012b\u02bf\u012b<\/em> elements but a strategic re-staging that maintained theological distinctiveness whilst absorbing emotional power. Consequently, this motif represents a more productive exploratory tool than \u2018hybridity\u2019 for comprehending the manner in which cultural systems preserve fidelity to roots whilst transforming across linguistic and regional routes.<\/p><p>Haldar\u2019s historical argument unfolds through a sophisticated analysis of how Karbala-centred narratives functioned as dynamic sites for working out fundamental tensions in Bengali Muslim identity formation. Chapter 1 reveals how the transition from oral-scribal culture to print created multiple ambivalences that became foundational to reformist modes of literary modernisation, with various authors creating \u2018speech-act texts\u2019 (p.43) that enabled their readers to participate in ritualistic performance whilst maintaining reformist authenticity through scriptural citation. Chapter 2 demonstrates how some members of the reformist ulema repositioned the figure of Husayn within Sunni theological frameworks whilst preserving the emotional power of martyrdom narratives. In this way, they generated pro-Caliphate sentiment among Bengali Muslims through their strategic re-staging of an Islamic vision. Chapters 3 and 4 trace how this symbolic imagination enabled the institutional formation of a Bengali Muslim sense of national identity (<em>j\u0101t\u012byat\u0101<\/em>) in the 1880s. The voluminous body of periodicals published by networks (<em>anjuman<\/em>) reveals how modern Muslim publics emerged through styles of creative adaptation that sought to maintain trans-territorial Islamic connections whilst establishing regional literary authority. The development of a range of historical and biographical genres within these milieus created \u2018generic multivalence\u2019 (p.161) where poetry claimed historical truth and retellings of history employed poetic techniques, enabling Bengali Muslim authors to retrieve an age of Islamic glory from a Hindu-normative historical imagination. The culminating analysis in Chapter 5 shows how all these developments enabled Bengali Muslims to create a sophisticated style of multilingual and literary modernity through their \u2018composite Bangla\u2019 (p.221). They crafted a \u2018linguistic identity-in-difference\u2019 (p.281) that enabled multiple forms of belonging simultaneously. Thus, the return to <em>Dobh\u0101sh\u012b<\/em> traditions in the 1930s represented not a nostalgic retreat but an active redefinition of literary modernity that recovered Muslim literary heritage whilst maintaining reformist credentials.<\/p><p>For the field of Islamic studies, Haldar\u2019s framework provides new models for understanding reform movements that move beyond orthodox\/heterodox binaries. Her demonstration that reformist \u2018success\u2019 involved a skilful appropriation rather than an outright rejection of contested traditions offers key insights applicable also to contemporary Islamic movements navigating the vexed terrain between scriptural authority and local cultural practices. Haldar\u2019s analysis of authentication in terms of community-building mechanisms provides a luminous lens for understanding how religious authority operates in pluralistic contexts. More broadly, the work offers frameworks to scholars of religious studies for understanding how religious communities may navigate modernity through cultural production rather than institutional adaptation alone.<\/p><p>Whilst Haldar\u2019s theoretical sophistication and empirical richness make this a work of groundbreaking scholarship, the relationship between textual analysis and \u2018real-world\u2019 community formation requires more systematic examination. Whilst Haldar demonstrates how literary products created the conditions for identity formation, questions remain about reception practices, economic contexts of publication, and the social worlds of readers beyond elite literary circles. The concept of \u2018productive ambivalence\u2019 (p.144), while compelling, could benefit from more theoretical treatment such as Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak\u2019s postcolonial theorisation of \u2018strategic essentialism\u2019, whereby subaltern communities deploy seemingly fixed identities as tactical instruments for political mobilisation whilst maintaining awareness of their constructed nature.<\/p><p>Methodologically, some tension exists between Haldar\u2019s claims about \u2018popular\u2019 literature and the evident sophistication of much analysed material. This is because the <em>Dobh\u0101sh\u012b<\/em> texts reveal considerable theological and literary complexity, suggesting either a greater intellectual competence among Bengali Muslims than commonly assumed, or a limitation of these sources to relatively educated audiences despite their \u2018popular\u2019 designation. Moreover, Haldar\u2019s conceptualisation of \u2018Bengali Muslim identity\u2019 as a unified analytical category unfolds considerable geographical constraints that exacerbate these methodological issues. In fact, the emergence of \u2018Pak-Bangla\u2019 as a distinct category, articulated through claims such as: East Pakistan\u2019s literary tradition \u2018should be essentially different from that of West Bengal\u2019 (p. 283), can dialectically be interpreted as a departure from the pan-Bengali synthesis that had characterised the colonial period. Haldar\u2019s temporal scope, ending primarily at 1947, to a large extent critically limits her ability to address these territorial divisions, leaving Bengali Muslim identity development in West Bengal unexplored and raising questions about whether her concepts of \u2018productive ambivalence\u2019 and \u2018local cosmopolitanism\u2019 operated differently within a Hindu-majority versus Muslim-majority state context. On top of that, Bangladesh\u2019s assertion of independence in 1971, which introduced additional challenges where \u2018composite Bangla entered a different dynamic\u2019 through \u2018deliberate distancing of the intelligentsia from religious authorities\u2019 (p. 285), can be read as a moment when the cultural synthesis achieved through <em>j\u0101t\u012b\u1e8fa s\u0101hitya<\/em> underwent fundamental transformation under linguistic nationalism. This, in turn, suggests that Haldar\u2019s analytical frameworks may be more historically specific than their theoretical claims imply; they are, therefore, notably limiting their applicability to post-partition contexts where the notion of a unified \u2018Bengali identity\u2019 requires more systematic examination than her pre-partition focus provides.<\/p><p>Nevertheless, the work\u2019s lasting significance lies in its demonstration of how Bengali Muslims created a distinctive form of literary modernity through strategic cultural navigation rather than unreflective synthesis; unlike previous scholarship that has primarily focused on elite reformers or institutional changes, Haldar shows how popular literary culture itself became a site of theological negotiation, not merely cultural expression. Her multilingual archival approach reveals the interconnections between scriptural authentication, aesthetic innovation, and community formation across multiple genres, thereby extending the study of Bengali Muslim intellectual history beyond existing analyses of periodical culture and literary societies. The theoretical frameworks developed here are likely to be adopted widely by scholars working on religious modernisation, postcolonial literature, and comparative cultural studies. Most significantly, whilst existing scholarship has tended to treat South Asian Islam through either reformist or traditionalist lenses, Haldar\u2019s concept of \u2018productive ambivalence\u2019 provides a new analytical framework that captures the creative tensions within religious modernisation processes, with clear applications beyond the Bengali Muslim context. The work successfully bridges the gap between detailed historical analysis and broader theoretical intervention, demonstrating how careful empirical work can reshape fundamental assumptions about cultural formation and religious modernity. Haldar has produced scholarship that successfully avoids the curse of the middle path whilst providing concrete analytical tools for understanding how communities create sophisticated cultural solutions for complex historical challenges.<\/p><p>\u00a0<\/p><p>\u00a0<\/p><\/div><\/div><\/div>\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-element elementor-element-3e6dac0 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider\" data-id=\"3e6dac0\" data-element_type=\"widget\" data-widget_type=\"divider.default\">\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-container\">\n\t\t\t<style>\/*! elementor - v3.14.0 - 26-06-2023 *\/\n.elementor-widget-divider{--divider-border-style:none;--divider-border-width:1px;--divider-color:#0c0d0e;--divider-icon-size:20px;--divider-element-spacing:10px;--divider-pattern-height:24px;--divider-pattern-size:20px;--divider-pattern-url:none;--divider-pattern-repeat:repeat-x}.elementor-widget-divider .elementor-divider{display:flex}.elementor-widget-divider .elementor-divider__text{font-size:15px;line-height:1;max-width:95%}.elementor-widget-divider .elementor-divider__element{margin:0 var(--divider-element-spacing);flex-shrink:0}.elementor-widget-divider .elementor-icon{font-size:var(--divider-icon-size)}.elementor-widget-divider .elementor-divider-separator{display:flex;margin:0;direction:ltr}.elementor-widget-divider--view-line_icon .elementor-divider-separator,.elementor-widget-divider--view-line_text .elementor-divider-separator{align-items:center}.elementor-widget-divider--view-line_icon .elementor-divider-separator:after,.elementor-widget-divider--view-line_icon .elementor-divider-separator:before,.elementor-widget-divider--view-line_text .elementor-divider-separator:after,.elementor-widget-divider--view-line_text .elementor-divider-separator:before{display:block;content:\"\";border-bottom:0;flex-grow:1;border-top:var(--divider-border-width) var(--divider-border-style) var(--divider-color)}.elementor-widget-divider--element-align-left .elementor-divider .elementor-divider-separator>.elementor-divider__svg:first-of-type{flex-grow:0;flex-shrink:100}.elementor-widget-divider--element-align-left .elementor-divider-separator:before{content:none}.elementor-widget-divider--element-align-left .elementor-divider__element{margin-left:0}.elementor-widget-divider--element-align-right .elementor-divider .elementor-divider-separator>.elementor-divider__svg:last-of-type{flex-grow:0;flex-shrink:100}.elementor-widget-divider--element-align-right .elementor-divider-separator:after{content:none}.elementor-widget-divider--element-align-right .elementor-divider__element{margin-right:0}.elementor-widget-divider:not(.elementor-widget-divider--view-line_text):not(.elementor-widget-divider--view-line_icon) .elementor-divider-separator{border-top:var(--divider-border-width) var(--divider-border-style) var(--divider-color)}.elementor-widget-divider--separator-type-pattern{--divider-border-style:none}.elementor-widget-divider--separator-type-pattern.elementor-widget-divider--view-line .elementor-divider-separator,.elementor-widget-divider--separator-type-pattern:not(.elementor-widget-divider--view-line) .elementor-divider-separator:after,.elementor-widget-divider--separator-type-pattern:not(.elementor-widget-divider--view-line) .elementor-divider-separator:before,.elementor-widget-divider--separator-type-pattern:not([class*=elementor-widget-divider--view]) .elementor-divider-separator{width:100%;min-height:var(--divider-pattern-height);-webkit-mask-size:var(--divider-pattern-size) 100%;mask-size:var(--divider-pattern-size) 100%;-webkit-mask-repeat:var(--divider-pattern-repeat);mask-repeat:var(--divider-pattern-repeat);background-color:var(--divider-color);-webkit-mask-image:var(--divider-pattern-url);mask-image:var(--divider-pattern-url)}.elementor-widget-divider--no-spacing{--divider-pattern-size:auto}.elementor-widget-divider--bg-round{--divider-pattern-repeat:round}.rtl .elementor-widget-divider .elementor-divider__text{direction:rtl}.e-con-inner>.elementor-widget-divider,.e-con>.elementor-widget-divider{width:var(--container-widget-width,100%);--flex-grow:var(--container-widget-flex-grow)}<\/style>\t\t<div class=\"elementor-divider\">\n\t\t\t<span class=\"elementor-divider-separator\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/span>\n\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/section>\n\t\t\t\t<section class=\"elementor-section elementor-top-section elementor-element elementor-element-71a712d9 elementor-section-boxed elementor-section-height-default elementor-section-height-default\" data-id=\"71a712d9\" data-element_type=\"section\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-container elementor-column-gap-default\">\n\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-column elementor-col-50 elementor-top-column elementor-element elementor-element-6a2579e5\" data-id=\"6a2579e5\" data-element_type=\"column\">\n\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-wrap elementor-element-populated\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-element elementor-element-2681bf9e elementor-align-right elementor-mobile-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button\" data-id=\"2681bf9e\" data-element_type=\"widget\" data-widget_type=\"button.default\">\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-container\">\n\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-button-wrapper\">\n\t\t\t<a class=\"elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm\" href=\"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/09\/Beyond-Synthesis-A-Review-of-Epsita-Haldars-\u2018Reclaiming-Karbala.pdf\" target=\"_blank\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<span class=\"elementor-button-content-wrapper\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<span class=\"elementor-button-icon elementor-align-icon-left\">\n\t\t\t\t<svg xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" id=\"Layer_2\" data-name=\"Layer 2\" viewBox=\"0 0 24.1 24.1\"><g id=\"Layer_1-2\" data-name=\"Layer 1\"><path d=\"M13.35,7.28l1.73,1.73c3.35,3.35,3.35,8.79,0,12.14l-.43,.43c-3.35,3.35-8.79,3.35-12.14,0-3.35-3.35-3.35-8.79,0-12.14l1.73,1.73c-2.39,2.39-2.39,6.28,0,8.67,2.39,2.39,6.28,2.39,8.67,0l.43-.43c2.39-2.39,2.39-6.28,0-8.67l-1.73-1.73,1.73-1.73Zm8.24,7.37l-1.73-1.73c2.39-2.39,2.39-6.28,0-8.67-2.39-2.39-6.28-2.39-8.67,0l-.43,.43c-2.39,2.39-2.39,6.28,0,8.67l1.73,1.73-1.73,1.73-1.73-1.73c-3.35-3.35-3.35-8.79,0-12.14l.43-.43c3.35-3.35,8.79-3.35,12.14,0,3.35,3.35,3.35,8.79,0,12.14Z\"><\/path><\/g><\/svg>\t\t\t<\/span>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<span class=\"elementor-button-text\">Download Pdf<\/span>\n\t\t<\/span>\n\t\t\t\t\t<\/a>\n\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-column elementor-col-50 elementor-top-column elementor-element elementor-element-358871f9\" data-id=\"358871f9\" data-element_type=\"column\">\n\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-wrap elementor-element-populated\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-element elementor-element-3f1eb0d2 elementor-align-left elementor-tablet-align-center elementor-mobile-align-center copy-post-url-button elementor-widget elementor-widget-button\" data-id=\"3f1eb0d2\" data-element_type=\"widget\" data-widget_type=\"button.default\">\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-container\">\n\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-button-wrapper\">\n\t\t\t<a class=\"elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm\" href=\"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/?p=2629\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<span class=\"elementor-button-content-wrapper\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<span class=\"elementor-button-icon elementor-align-icon-left\">\n\t\t\t\t<svg xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" id=\"Layer_2\" data-name=\"Layer 2\" viewBox=\"0 0 24.1 24.1\"><g id=\"Layer_1-2\" data-name=\"Layer 1\"><path d=\"M13.35,7.28l1.73,1.73c3.35,3.35,3.35,8.79,0,12.14l-.43,.43c-3.35,3.35-8.79,3.35-12.14,0-3.35-3.35-3.35-8.79,0-12.14l1.73,1.73c-2.39,2.39-2.39,6.28,0,8.67,2.39,2.39,6.28,2.39,8.67,0l.43-.43c2.39-2.39,2.39-6.28,0-8.67l-1.73-1.73,1.73-1.73Zm8.24,7.37l-1.73-1.73c2.39-2.39,2.39-6.28,0-8.67-2.39-2.39-6.28-2.39-8.67,0l-.43,.43c-2.39,2.39-2.39,6.28,0,8.67l1.73,1.73-1.73,1.73-1.73-1.73c-3.35-3.35-3.35-8.79,0-12.14l.43-.43c3.35-3.35,8.79-3.35,12.14,0,3.35,3.35,3.35,8.79,0,12.14Z\"><\/path><\/g><\/svg>\t\t\t<\/span>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<span class=\"elementor-button-text\">Copy the Link<\/span>\n\t\t<\/span>\n\t\t\t\t\t<\/a>\n\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/section>\n\t\t\t\t<section class=\"elementor-section elementor-top-section elementor-element elementor-element-3db0cf82 elementor-section-boxed elementor-section-height-default elementor-section-height-default\" data-id=\"3db0cf82\" data-element_type=\"section\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-container elementor-column-gap-default\">\n\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-column elementor-col-100 elementor-top-column elementor-element elementor-element-4069f7b7\" data-id=\"4069f7b7\" data-element_type=\"column\">\n\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-wrap elementor-element-populated\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-element elementor-element-41b76829 elementor-widget elementor-widget-html\" data-id=\"41b76829\" data-element_type=\"widget\" data-widget_type=\"html.default\">\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-container\">\n\t\t\t<style>\n\/* Styling for the copy message on all devices *\/\n.copy-message {\n  position: fixed;\n  top: 50%;\n  left: 50%;\n  transform: translate(-50%, -50%);\n  background-color: #b89272;\n  color: white;\n  padding: 15px 30px;\n  border-radius: 5px;\n  z-index: 9999;\n  font-family: sans-serif;\n  font-size: 18px; \/* Standard font size for desktop *\/\n  opacity: 0;\n  transition: opacity 0.3s ease-in-out;\n}\n\n\/* Adjustments for smaller screens (e.g., mobile phones) *\/\n@media screen and (max-width: 768px) {\n  .copy-message {\n    font-size: 14px; \/* Smaller font size for mobile *\/\n    padding: 10px 20px;\n  }\n}\n<\/style>\n\n<script>\ndocument.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function() {\n  const copyButtons = document.querySelectorAll('.copy-post-url-button a');\n\n  copyButtons.forEach(button => {\n    button.addEventListener('click', function(e) {\n      e.stopImmediatePropagation();\n      e.preventDefault();\n\n      const postUrl = this.href;\n\n      navigator.clipboard.writeText(postUrl)\n        .then(() => {\n          const messageDiv = document.createElement('div');\n          messageDiv.textContent = 'Link has been copied!';\n          messageDiv.classList.add('copy-message');\n          \n          document.body.appendChild(messageDiv);\n          \n          setTimeout(() => { messageDiv.style.opacity = '1'; }, 10);\n          setTimeout(() => {\n            messageDiv.style.opacity = '0';\n            setTimeout(() => messageDiv.remove(), 300);\n          }, 2000);\n        })\n        .catch(err => {\n          console.error('Could not copy URL: ', err);\n          alert('Could not copy URL.');\n        });\n    });\n  });\n});\n<\/script>\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/section>\n\t\t\t\t<section class=\"elementor-section elementor-top-section elementor-element elementor-element-29e0cae3 elementor-section-boxed elementor-section-height-default elementor-section-height-default\" data-id=\"29e0cae3\" data-element_type=\"section\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-container elementor-column-gap-default\">\n\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-column elementor-col-100 elementor-top-column elementor-element elementor-element-2fbf1f04\" data-id=\"2fbf1f04\" data-element_type=\"column\">\n\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-wrap elementor-element-populated\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-element elementor-element-78538229 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider\" data-id=\"78538229\" data-element_type=\"widget\" data-widget_type=\"divider.default\">\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-container\">\n\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-divider\">\n\t\t\t<span class=\"elementor-divider-separator\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/span>\n\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-element elementor-element-34a1f9cf elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading\" data-id=\"34a1f9cf\" data-element_type=\"widget\" data-widget_type=\"heading.default\">\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-container\">\n\t\t\t<h2 class=\"elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default\">Share this article<\/h2>\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-element elementor-element-7e9eceae elementor-share-buttons--view-icon elementor-share-buttons--skin-flat elementor-share-buttons--shape-circle elementor-share-buttons--align-center elementor-grid-0 elementor-share-buttons--color-official elementor-widget elementor-widget-share-buttons\" data-id=\"7e9eceae\" data-element_type=\"widget\" data-widget_type=\"share-buttons.default\">\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-container\">\n\t\t\t<link rel=\"stylesheet\" href=\"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/wp-content\/plugins\/elementor-pro\/assets\/css\/widget-share-buttons.min.css\">\t\t<div class=\"elementor-grid\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-grid-item\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<div\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\tclass=\"elementor-share-btn elementor-share-btn_whatsapp\"\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\trole=\"button\"\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\ttabindex=\"0\"\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\taria-label=\"Share on whatsapp\"\n\t\t\t\t\t\t>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<span class=\"elementor-share-btn__icon\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<i class=\"fab fa-whatsapp\" aria-hidden=\"true\"><\/i>\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/span>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-grid-item\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<div\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\tclass=\"elementor-share-btn elementor-share-btn_facebook\"\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\trole=\"button\"\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\ttabindex=\"0\"\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\taria-label=\"Share on facebook\"\n\t\t\t\t\t\t>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<span class=\"elementor-share-btn__icon\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<i class=\"fab fa-facebook\" aria-hidden=\"true\"><\/i>\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/span>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-grid-item\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<div\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\tclass=\"elementor-share-btn elementor-share-btn_linkedin\"\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\trole=\"button\"\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\ttabindex=\"0\"\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\taria-label=\"Share on linkedin\"\n\t\t\t\t\t\t>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<span class=\"elementor-share-btn__icon\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<i class=\"fab fa-linkedin\" aria-hidden=\"true\"><\/i>\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/span>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/section>\n\t\t\t\t<section class=\"elementor-section elementor-top-section elementor-element elementor-element-71693b9 elementor-section-boxed elementor-section-height-default elementor-section-height-default\" data-id=\"71693b9\" data-element_type=\"section\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-container elementor-column-gap-default\">\n\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-column elementor-col-100 elementor-top-column elementor-element elementor-element-367e38d9\" data-id=\"367e38d9\" data-element_type=\"column\">\n\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-wrap elementor-element-populated\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-element elementor-element-b3f410b heading-with-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading\" data-id=\"b3f410b\" data-element_type=\"widget\" data-widget_type=\"heading.default\">\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-container\">\n\t\t\t<h2 class=\"elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default\">Related Tags<\/h2>\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/section>\n\t\t\t\t<section class=\"elementor-section elementor-top-section elementor-element elementor-element-86b8944 elementor-section-boxed elementor-section-height-default elementor-section-height-default\" data-id=\"86b8944\" data-element_type=\"section\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-container elementor-column-gap-default\">\n\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-column elementor-col-100 elementor-top-column elementor-element elementor-element-c23289a\" data-id=\"c23289a\" data-element_type=\"column\">\n\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-wrap elementor-element-populated\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-element elementor-element-54572b8 elementor-widget elementor-widget-shortcode\" data-id=\"54572b8\" data-element_type=\"widget\" data-widget_type=\"shortcode.default\">\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-container\">\n\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-shortcode\"><div class=\"posts-tags\"><a href=\"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/?tag=bengali-muslims\" rel=\"tag\">Bengali Muslims<\/a> <a href=\"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/?tag=book-review\" rel=\"tag\">Book Review<\/a> <a href=\"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/?tag=epsita-haldar\" rel=\"tag\">Epsita Haldar<\/a> <a href=\"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/?tag=islamic-studies\" rel=\"tag\">Islamic Studies<\/a> <a href=\"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/?tag=reclaiming-karbala\" rel=\"tag\">Reclaiming Karbala<\/a><\/div><\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/section>\n\t\t\t\t<section class=\"elementor-section elementor-top-section elementor-element elementor-element-2382b2a elementor-section-boxed elementor-section-height-default elementor-section-height-default\" data-id=\"2382b2a\" data-element_type=\"section\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-container elementor-column-gap-default\">\n\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-column elementor-col-100 elementor-top-column elementor-element elementor-element-de704ea\" data-id=\"de704ea\" data-element_type=\"column\">\n\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-wrap elementor-element-populated\">\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-element elementor-element-b3f3f49 heading-with-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading\" data-id=\"b3f3f49\" data-element_type=\"widget\" data-widget_type=\"heading.default\">\n\t\t\t\t<div class=\"elementor-widget-container\">\n\t\t\t<h2 class=\"elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default\">Explore more articles<\/h2>\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t<\/section>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t<\/div>\n\t\t\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Summary In Reclaiming Karbala, Epsita Haldar challenges traditional views on religious modernization and cultural formation among Bengali Muslims. She argues that they developed a unique form of modernity by embracing &#8220;productive ambivalence,&#8221; navigating cultural and religious tensions without a &#8220;facile synthesis.&#8221; The book demonstrates how they used a &#8220;contact nebula&#8221; of multilingual sources and created [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":10,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"inline_featured_image":false,"footnotes":""},"categories":[1],"tags":[89,86,87,90,88],"class_list":["post-2629","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-blog","tag-bengali-muslims","tag-book-review","tag-epsita-haldar","tag-islamic-studies","tag-reclaiming-karbala"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2629","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/users\/10"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcomments&post=2629"}],"version-history":[{"count":19,"href":"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2629\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":2651,"href":"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2629\/revisions\/2651"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fmedia&parent=2629"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcategories&post=2629"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/projectmishkat.org\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Ftags&post=2629"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}